
Karnataka: Governor Refuses to Read Government’s Speech in Assembly, Congress Creates Uproar
Bengaluru: Karnataka Governor Thawarchand Gehlot on Thursday refused to read the traditional address prepared by the Congress-led state government during the joint session of the state legislature. The Governor limited his address to just a few lines and abruptly concluded it, triggering chaos and confusion inside the Assembly premises. The incident has further deepened the ongoing tension between the Governor and the ruling Congress government.
Addressing the joint session, Governor Gehlot stated that his government is fully committed to ensuring social, economic, and physical development. He ended his brief speech with the slogans “Jai Hind” and “Jai Karnataka.” Following this, members of both Houses and the Legislative Council were left standing in confusion. As soon as the Governor stepped down from the Speaker’s chair, Congress legislators began raising slogans against him. In response, BJP legislators supported the Governor, congratulated him, and raised slogans of “Bharat Mata Ki Jai.”
The situation turned tense when Congress MLAs and MLCs tried to stop the Governor and demanded that he read the complete speech prepared by the government. Congress MLC B.K. Hariprasad attempted to question the Governor in anger. Marshals had to intervene to control the situation and clear a path for the Governor to exit the House. During this process, Hariprasad also opposed the marshals, leading to further disorder and commotion in the House for some time.
Earlier in the day, there were speculations that the Governor might skip the joint session, but he arrived at the Assembly at the scheduled time. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah welcomed him by presenting a bouquet. Assembly Speaker U.T. Khader and Legislative Council Chairman Basavaraj Horatti were also present on the occasion.
Following the incident, the political controversy intensified. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah strongly condemned the Governor’s action, alleging that by delivering a self-prepared brief address instead of the government-drafted speech, the Governor violated constitutional norms. He said that Articles 176 and 163 of the Indian Constitution clearly state that the Governor is required to read the speech prepared by the government on the advice of the Council of Ministers. The Chief Minister accused the Governor of violating the Constitution and insulting the House of elected representatives.
Siddaramaiah further stated that his government is seriously considering approaching the Supreme Court over the matter. He emphasized that this is not merely a political issue but one related to constitutional values.
Earlier, State Law and Parliamentary Affairs Minister H.K. Patil had also warned that if the Governor failed to read the government-prepared speech during the joint session, it would amount to a betrayal of the Constitution. He had told reporters that addressing the joint session under Article 176 is a constitutional duty of the Governor.
The Governor had earlier asked the state government to remove 11 paragraphs from the Cabinet-approved speech. These paragraphs reportedly contained remarks on the central government’s policies, particularly concerning programmes related to Viksit Bharat, employment, and livelihoods. On Wednesday, a delegation led by the state Law Minister had met the Governor to discuss the issue and stated that a final decision would be taken after consulting the Chief Minister.
The Governor’s move has pushed Karnataka toward a major constitutional and political confrontation, raising the possibility of intensified political tensions in the state in the coming days.